Best Islay Single Malts to Buy (2026): 4 to Try Now
Best Islay Single Malts to Buy (2026)
Buying Guides
3 min readDeepak Bali
“Quick answer: The best Islay single malts to buy right now are Laphroaig 10 (£39.99) for big peat smoke, Bowmore 12 (£37.40) for gentle smoke and fruit, Bunnahabhain 12 (£37.99) for an unpeated, nutty Islay, and Bunnahabhain Stiùireadair (£26.99) for sherried value. All four are in stock now.
Islay (say it “eye-la”) is a small island off Scotland’s west coast, and it’s home to some of the most famous malts in the world. Most people know Islay whisky for its smoke: barley dried over peat fires gives it that bonfire, seaweed and iodine character.
But not every Islay malt is smoky. Some distilleries make soft, fruity or sherried whiskies that still carry a touch of the sea. Below are four Islay single malts we stock, from the boldest to the gentlest, so you can find the one that suits you.
The best Islay single malts to buy
1. Laphroaig 10 Year Old: best for peat lovers
If you want the classic Islay experience, this is it. Laphroaig 10 opens with heavy peat smoke and seaweed, with a sweet edge underneath. On the palate it’s medicinal and salty, with hints of vanilla and fruit, and the finish lasts a long time. People tend to love it or hate it, but it’s one of the best-known Islay malts for a reason.
Written by
Deepak Bali
I’ve been exploring whisky since 1996, combining nearly three decades of knowledge and firsthand tasting experience. In 1999, my master’s degree work focused on my own whisky website. Every whisky I review is personally tasted, independently assessed and scored out of 100 using a consistent five-stage framework. My judgement is guided by what’s in the glass, never by brand reputation or price.
Bowmore sits in the middle of the island and in the middle of the smoke scale. You get lemon and heather honey on the nose with a gentle, earthy smoke, then warm fruit and dark chocolate on the palate. The smoke stays sweet and soft to the end. It’s a good bridge if you’re new to peated whisky.
Proof that Islay isn’t all smoke. Bunnahabhain 12 is unpeated, with bright fruit, floral notes and a hint of dried fruit on the nose. The palate brings sweet fruit, nuts, vanilla and caramel, and the finish is rich with a little sea salt. Bottled at 46.3%, it has a fuller body than most 12-year-olds.
Stiùireadair (Gaelic for “helmsman”) is Bunnahabhain’s sherried, unpeated malt. Expect dried fruit, caramel, vanilla and nuts with a touch of brine on the nose, then a creamy palate of sweet dried fruit and sea salt. The dried-fruit finish lingers. At under £30, it’s the best-value Islay malt on our shelf.
Love smoke? Go straight for Laphroaig 10. If you want to see how Laphroaig compares on price across its range, read our Laphroaig price guide.
New to peat? Start with Bowmore 12. The smoke is there, but it’s balanced by honey and fruit.
Don’t like smoke at all? Choose either Bunnahabhain. The 12 Year Old is fruity and nutty, and Stiùireadair leans towards sherry and dried fruit.
Buying a gift? If you don’t know their taste, an unpeated Bunnahabhain is the safer bet. If they already drink smoky whisky, Laphroaig 10 won’t disappoint.
How to drink it: try a small pour neat, then add a few drops of water. Water softens the smoke and brings out the fruit, especially in the 46.3% Bunnahabhains.
FAQs
What is the best Islay single malt?
It depends on how much smoke you like. For heavy peat, Laphroaig 10. For gentle smoke, Bowmore 12. For no smoke at all, Bunnahabhain 12.
Are all Islay whiskies smoky?
No. Most Islay distilleries are known for peated whisky, but Bunnahabhain makes mostly unpeated malts, including the 12 Year Old and Stiùireadair.
What is the smokiest Islay malt?
Of the four on this list, Laphroaig 10 is by far the smokiest.
How many distilleries are on Islay?
At the time of writing there are ten working distilleries on the island, including Laphroaig, Bowmore, Bunnahabhain, Lagavulin, Ardbeg and Caol Ila.
What’s a good Islay whisky for a beginner?
Bowmore 12 if you want to try peat, or Bunnahabhain 12 if you’d rather start without smoke.
What is the cheapest Islay single malt you sell?
Bunnahabhain Stiùireadair, at £26.99 (16 November 2026).
Shop Islay whisky
From heavy peat to soft and sherried, browse every Islay single malt on our shelf, shipped from Dunfermline, Scotland.
Please drink responsibly. You must be 18 or over to buy alcohol.
Quick answer: For a St Andrew’s Day toast, pick a single malt that shows off a part of Scotland. The Glenlivet 12 (Speyside) is the easy crowd-pleaser. Aberfeldy 12 (Highlands) brings heather honey. Laphroaig 10 (Islay) is for smoke lovers. Highland Park 15 Viking Heart (Orkney) makes the best gift. Loch Lomond The Original is…
Quick answer: If you love bourbon, start with Scotch matured in ex-bourbon casks. It carries the same vanilla, caramel and sweet oak notes you already enjoy. Try Jura 14 (£33.99), finished in American rye casks, or Glenlivet 12 (£34.99) for a smooth, sweet first step. If you fancy smoke, go for Laphroaig 10 (£39.99), aged…
Quick answer: The best whisky for a whisky sour is a smooth, fruity Scotch that stands up to fresh lemon without being overpowered. Our top pick is Glenlivet 12 (£34.99). For a richer sour, use Aberlour 12 (£36.69). For a smoky twist, use Bowmore 12 (£37.40). On a budget, Bunnahabhain Stiùireadair (£26.99) is excellent. (Prices…